1988 Chevy TBi - Mystery Misfire
Problem is I cannot find any reason for it!
Swapped the spark plugs and leads around but in any case now the engine has new plugs, wires and a new distributor. Compression and 100psi leakdown test showed no big issues, the "bad" cyclinder had aroud 25% leakage, another one only 15-20% but. A scope on the injectors showed a regular square wave, no gaps. I double checked the firing order and I checked the valve clearances and watched the valves opening for the correct plug position on the distributor and with the cylinder at TDC. Even took the intake off to check for blockages.
I have been trying to do ignition waveforms and I get a decent one off the coil king lead, but the problem is I cannot get a trigger of one of the plug leads. I am using Hantek 1008c with the HT25 pickups. On the plug lead (tried multiple differnt) the waveform is a complete mess, it sometimes shows a waveform but not consistently to get a trigger. I tried also using my PeakTech 4250 current clamp as a pickup on a plug wire and this just caused random peaks in the waveform, nothing I could get a trigger from.
I got a waveform anyway covering all 8 cyclinders at warm idle (attached) and I don't see any obvious problem with one cyclinder anyway, but can't do a snap throttle test easily without knowing which cylinder i'm looking at.
Any ideas appreciated!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Compare to another known good cylinder (or two) for reference. A difference in running compression represents a difference in cylinder breathing, which can account for your misfire.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Hardtopdr2
- Offline
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 834
- Thank you received: 138
Also this could be a case of some weak valvesprings but lets just go down the list of what everyone listed.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- juergen.scholl
- Offline
- Platinum Member
- Active partschanger
- Posts: 1195
- Thank you received: 446
The sampling rate of the scope combined with the selected screen time does not allow for an analysis of the ignition wave form......
An expert is someone who knows each time more on each time less, until he finally knows absolutely everything about absolutely nothing.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
The cyclinder in question is #5 sharing the intake runner with #8. Off this runner is the main vacuum intake for the cruise, accumulator etc (closer to #8 than #5) but I smoke tested it and didn't see anything obvious. Can do it again to be sure. #8 seemed to be fine with a drop test, plug condition etc.
I did a compression test a while ago and it was around 130 psi I believe with a couple of other cylinders at 150 psi but I will re-do one on a few different cylinders, I will try this.
The injector waveform is a good point - this was done with the injector connectors off and just cranking as they are pretty sealed up and I don't see an obvious way to backprobe them. Will try and work out a way to a get a waveform pattern with them running.
I can do a leakdown test again with a couple more cylinders. I agree 25% could be significant compared to 15% on cylinder 7, I was just going off it was still in the green area of the gauge.
I really like the idea of shorting another plug to ground to see which one of the waveforms is the missing cvlinder, but I'm not sure it helps getting me any further in terms of focusing in on the missing cylinder waveform to get it in a decent amount of detail and test what it does at high rpm/snap throttle etc. It's really frustrating I can't get a decent trigger signal of the plug lead, as I assumed this must be possible as they use plug lead pickups for timing lights etc. I can try my setup on another distributor vehicle to see if it shows anything up.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
eumecon wrote: I really like the idea of shorting another plug to ground to see which one of the waveforms is the missing cvlinder, but I'm not sure it helps getting me any further in terms of focusing in on the missing cylinder waveform to get it in a decent amount of detail and test what it does at high rpm/snap throttle etc. It's really frustrating I can't get a decent trigger signal of the plug lead, as I assumed this must be possible as they use plug lead pickups for timing lights etc. I can try my setup on another distributor vehicle to see if it shows anything up.
If you've got a timing light you could try opening it up and 'scoping its trigger signal. Or an automotive DMMs RPM pickup also works.
www.scannerdanner.com/forum/lab-scope-di...ico-2205a.html#42534
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Hardtopdr2
- Offline
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 834
- Thank you received: 138
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Pressures were
Cyl 5 (dead miss) and 7 (ok): 205psi
Cyl 6 and 8 (both ok): 180psi
The plugs all also look fine, far left is number 5, slight browning but others also showed evidence of this. Previously the number 5 looked a little wet, but this was after a lot of idle as opposed to now after a lot of motorway miles.
- The suggestion of using a timing light pickup was great, I realised I actually had a clamp like that for an old multimeter and it works perfectly, can now get the seondary waveform with a trigger! No idea why the amp clamp didn't show anything similar. This is waveform at idle
Comparing against the next cyclinder I don't see anything too extreme
And under snap throttle
I also checked and double checked the plug wire and it is on securely and the plug definitely fires outside the cylinder. So it seems I have ruled most things out, again! Thoughts on the waveforms appreciated....
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
I'm not too expert at catching misfires through secondary ignition wave forms, but according to Paul's book, that seems you have a lean condition (not only in a single cylinder).
I'm in the process of adapting a complete TBI chevy system to a 1970 Toyota FJ40. To set this thing up (without scanner), I had to perform many old school tricks that can be useful to rule a lean condition out.
Just to enrich the mixture a little bit, you can add a resistor in series with ECT sensor (let's say 330 ohms for this little lean condition you are facing). This won't hurt anything for your test.
I think this test can give any direction in order you have proven a lot of things and you still don't know the root cause of misfire.
You can get same results by increasing fuel pressure. This can be done by adding force to the spring inside pressure regulator or by strangling a little bit the fuel return line.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.